In Arizona, facing criminal charges is a daunting and complex journey. The moments leading up to an alleged crime can be filled with confusion and fear, especially when intoxication is involved.
Understanding the law surrounding the impact of intoxication on criminal responsibility is crucial for those arrested and facing a criminal charge.
Skilled attorneys at Colburn Hintze Maletta (CHM) stand ready to guide individuals through this challenging process with expertise and compassion.
Get Immediate Help from Our Criminal Defense Attorneys.
We are Available to Talk Now.
Or, Continue Reading Below About:
Intoxication Defense in Arizona
Understanding Intoxication as a Legal Defense
Under Arizona law, a clear distinction is made between voluntary and involuntary intoxication and their use as defenses in criminal proceedings.
Voluntary Intoxication and Its Limits
Voluntary intoxication, where an individual consciously consumes alcohol or drugs, is generally not a defense against committing an offense (State v. Hudson, 85 Ariz. 77; State v. Kabinto, 106 Ariz. 575).
Arizona Revised Statutes (ARS) 13-503 highlights the effect of alcohol or drug use, emphasizing that voluntary intoxication does not excuse criminal conduct.
Exceptions and Specific Circumstances
There are nuanced exceptions, particularly in cases of specific intent crimes.
For instance, in scenarios involving alleged assault with intent to murder, intoxication may be considered to determine the accused’s ability to form a deliberate and premeditated intent to kill (Hackett v. Territory, 5 Ariz. 251).
Involuntary Intoxication as a Defense
Involuntary intoxication stands on different legal grounds.
This defense applies when intoxication results from the non-abusive use of prescription medication, as per a doctor’s instructions, and can negate the mental state required for a crime. (State v. Leteve, 237 Ariz. 516).
Arizona courts also recognize involuntary intoxication to challenge specific intent in crimes, provided it’s shown that such intoxication rendered the defendant incapable of forming the requisite criminal intent.
Illustrative Example: Voluntary vs. Involuntary Intoxication
To better understand the distinction between voluntary and involuntary intoxication in the context of Arizona law, let’s consider a hypothetical example:
The Hypothetical Case of Alex and Jordan
Alex spends an evening at a local bar and consumes several drinks. Feeling emboldened by the alcohol, Alex gets into a confrontation and assaults another patron.
This action is a result of voluntary intoxication, as Alex chose to consume alcohol and then engaged in criminal behavior.
Under Arizona law, Alex’s state of intoxication from his consumption of alcohol would not serve as a defense to the assault charge because the intoxication was voluntary.
Alex’s decision to drink and subsequent aggressive behavior illustrates how voluntary intoxication complicates the legal defense, typically leaving the individual fully accountable for their actions.
In contrast, Jordan is at a friend’s house, where they unknowingly consume a beverage spiked with a potent drug. Unaware of the intoxication, Jordan becomes disoriented and unintentionally damages property.
In this scenario, Jordan’s intoxication is involuntary—a critical factor that significantly affects legal defense.
Arizona recognizes involuntary intoxication as a potential defense if it can be proven that Jordan was incapable of understanding or controlling their actions due to the drug’s effects.
This defense hinges on the lack of intent and knowledge regarding the intoxication, offering a potential exoneration path.
Legal Implications and Defense Strategies
These scenarios underscore the legal system’s nuanced approach to intoxication:
- Voluntary Intoxication: The law clearly states that voluntary intoxication does not excuse criminal behavior. However, it might impact sentencing or be considered in cases requiring specific intent to commit a crime.
- Legal strategies might focus on mitigating circumstances or negotiating pleas rather than directly defending against the charges.
- Involuntary Intoxication: This condition introduces a viable defense, especially when it negates the requisite mental state for the crime.
- Defense strategies may involve medical evidence, witness testimony, and expert analysis to prove the lack of knowledge and control over one’s actions due to involuntary intoxication.
The distinction between voluntary and involuntary intoxication highlights the importance of intent and knowledge in criminal liability.
It also emphasizes the critical role of skilled legal representation from lawyers at firms like Colburn Hintze Maletta in navigating these complex defenses.
Understanding the nuances of each case, CHM is adept at crafting strategies that address the specific circumstances and legal implications of intoxication-related charges.
The Impact of Preexisting Conditions
When assessing the role of intoxication in criminal conduct, Arizona courts take into account not just the act of becoming intoxicated but also how preexisting mental conditions might influence an individual’s susceptibility to intoxicants.
This nuanced approach can significantly affect the outcome of cases where intent is a pivotal element.
The Hypothetical Scenario Involving Chris
Consider the case of Chris, a fictional individual with a diagnosed neurological condition that affects their cognitive functioning and impulse control. Chris is on medication to manage this condition, which, unknown to them, interacts adversely with alcohol.
One evening, Chris consumes a moderate amount of alcohol at a social gathering.
The combination of their medication and the alcohol severely impairs Chris’s judgment and behavior, leading to an altercation and subsequent charges of assault.
Legal Considerations and Defense
In this hypothetical scenario, Chris’s defense team can argue that due to their preexisting neurological condition and the unforeseen interaction with alcohol, Chris lacked the requisite intent to commit assault.
This argument draws on legal precedents such as the case of State v. James Robinson, where the courts acknowledged that a defendant’s susceptibility to intoxicants, due to a preexisting condition, could impact their capacity to form intent.
Evidence could include medical records, expert testimony on Chris’s condition, and the unpredictable effects of the medication when combined with alcohol.
This approach doesn’t excuse the criminal behavior but seeks to provide a context that may mitigate responsibility or lead to alternative sentencing.
Conclusion
In Arizona, the defense of intoxication in criminal cases is nuanced. Significant legal penalties depend on the nature of the intoxication and the specific charges.
While voluntary intoxication rarely serves as a complete defense, nuances in the law and exceptions, particularly around involuntary intoxication and specific intent crimes, highlight the complexity of these cases.
Colburn Hintze Maletta is a law firm that provides expert legal guidance, ensuring that those accused of crimes, where intoxication is a factor, receive a defense that is both compassionate and legally sound.
Facing criminal charges is never easy, but with CHM, you’re not alone on this journey. Our goal is to navigate the legal system with you, offering support, expertise, and hope every step of the way. Contact us today for a free consultation at (602) 825-2500.
David Maletta is a widely respected criminal defense attorney with over 23 years of experience and has worked on over 1,000 cases and has successfully won over 100 jury trials. David graduated from Northern Arizona University, Magna Cum Laude in 1993 with a degree in Psychology. Shortly thereafter, he earned his Juris Doctor degree from Seton Hall University School of Law in 1998. He has extensive experience in criminal and DUI matters, homicide, sexually-based offenses, domestic violence, white-collar crimes, and various misdemeanor crimes.
Always Available 24/7 for Legal Help
Schedule an Appointment Today!
Call Us Now to Speak with an Attorney (602) 825-2500
Real Client Reviews
Below are just a few of what our clients have to say!
“Their service was by far the best! Couldn’t be happier”
Their service was by far the best! Couldn’t be happier, This firm had me at ease and with full confidence, took much of stress off. Can’t help to mention but thanks to Juanita for your patience with me.
Hose B - Google Review
“They are extremely capable and have great instincts”
Two of the partners of this firm supported me in some very contentious divorce issues. Darin and Tim are extremely capable and have great instincts on how to navigate sticky circumstances in a professional manner in front of Judges and court administrators. I found them to be understanding, time efficient, and sufficiently assertive to win my cases. For any Family Law or Criminal Defense situations, I would endorse and highly recommend this firm.
Vern Braaksma- Google Review
“She handled our case masterfully”
We had a great experience with Juanita. She handled our case masterfully, the process was smooth. Highly recommend.
Charne Gibson - Google Review
“The entire process was very efficient and smooth and it put me at ease”
I worked with Juanita to prepare a will and other legal documents for me. The entire process was very efficient and smooth and it put me at ease, and also they were very helpful in answering all of the questions I had. I highly recommend Juanita for your legal needs.
Nykelia Massingale - Google Review
“He made me feel like I was his number 1 priority”
Mr. Dave Maletta represented me in a legal matter that I had no idea where to start at. I contacted his office and they were very polite and made me feel comfortable from start to finish. Mr. Maletta was very thorough and professional! He returned my calls when I would leave a a message. He made me feel like I was his number 1 priority. Thank you again to the CHM office for everything you all did for me! I will definitely be recommending others to this place.
Living Life- Google Review
“She’s smart, driven, and supportive”
I highly recommend this law firm to anyone going through a family law case. They are awesome. Lauren Bostick was my attorney and she knows how to bring her A-game. She’s smart, driven, and supportive. Even after my case was finalized she has still answered questions for me and has stayed in communication to ensure that all is well. If you hire this firm I hope she is assigned to your case – but you can feel confident with any of the attorneys here. However, Lauren would be who I ask for if I need them again. Thank you Lauren for your support and help through all of my dramatic twists and turns of my case! You did an awesome job!!!!
Jeremy Chinavare - Google Review
“This team and office truly are miracle workers and genuinely care about you”
Called and spoke with a lady named Juanita. I told her my situation about a legal matter. She connected me with David who represented me. I had an ugly situation that could have cost me losing my job. David made sure all my questions were answered. What was really amazing was that Juanita would call to check up and make sure I knew what I needed and if I had any questions. This team and office truly are miracle workers and genuinely care about you. Thank you all again at CHM!
Martha Rentaria- Google Review
“I’m very amazed by their service and how smooth it is”
Amazing experience, very knowledgeable, thorough, and professional. I’m very amazed by their service and how smooth it is, especially with how much help I received with my case.
Hugo Esparza - Google Review
“I will, without hesitation, seek his counsel in the future if there is ever a need”
In a time of panic, Mr. Hintze proved to be invaluable I recently was denied a level one fingerprint clearance card through the Arizona Department of Public Safety as a result of a misdemeanor charge that occurred 16 years ago in my youth. This fingerprint card was the only thing standing between me and my ability to attend Arizona State University’s Edison College of Nursing. When I explained the details of my denial he immediately devised and executed a plan that ultimately resulted in me being awarded my fingerprint clearance card. Mr. Hintze’s confidence and steady demeaner brought a sense of relief to me, as I knew from the first conversation we had that his steadfast ability to navigate toward a productive resolution would be instrumental in my success. I appreciate Mr. Hintze beyond words and I will, without hesitation, seek his counsel in the future if there is ever a need.
Amanda - Avvo Review
“They have shown nothing but kindness and concern, and are always a step ahead”
I want to say thank you CHM Lawfirm for helping me get through some legal issues. Tim Hintze recently helped me in a legal case and he did an amazing job and is a magnificent lawyer! I could see that he was very passionate about helping me and had a genuine concern about exposing and fighting the false accusations against me. I would also like to thank Alysa Hudson and Whittney Stricker, who has been helping me in family court in a custody case for my child. They have shown nothing but kindness and concern, and are always a step ahead. I have confidence that they will lead me to a great outcome!
Hilario Serafin - Google Review
“David was relentless in his pursuit of my son’s innocence”
We retained David Maletta to represent our son after being cited for what can only be described as a momentary lapse of reason. David was extremely knowledgeable, was able to clearly communicate very complicated concepts, and was relentless in his pursuit of my son’s innocence. He had strong relationships with the prosecuting attorney and respect of the judge, which ultimately resulted in my son learning a really hard lesson with limited consequences (traffic school and writing an essay to the judge on the physics of driving 130MPH and what happens if that goes badly). I have already sent all of my friends with teenage and 20 year old kids his contact information for when they inevitably get that call. David completely exceeded all of our expectations and we could not recommend him any stronger. Thank you for everything.
Shawn H. - Google Review
“He was very kind and courteous”
Mr. David Maletta was very kind and courteous when he called me I explained my situation and he listened and then told me that I was fine. When I need a lawyer I will go through this firm and not be worried at all. Thank you again Mr. Maletta
Harold W Garlock Jr - Google Review
“I was impressed with his knowledge and quick response to my needs”
David Maletta is very detailed in his explanation of legal procedures. I was impressed with his knowledge and quick response to my needs. He instantly made me feel at ease. He is very professional, caring, and trustworthy. I highly recommend his services.
Diane Matelich - Google Review
“Forever grateful I chose this practice for my representation”
David Maletta is nothing short of a miracle worker. While I don’t believe anyone looks forward to hiring an attorney, David makes the legal process as stress free as it can be and does not give up until you obtain the outcome he is working towards. Forever grateful I chose this practice for my representation.
Michelle DeDora- Google Review
“He was the most professional in dealing with this case”
Tim was most professional in dealing with this case. I know it was stressful for all waiting on doctors and getting the reports. He was able to explain things to my husband even with him being highly frustrated. He kept us all informed. Thank you, Tim!
Neata - Avvo Review
“Best injury lawyers in Phoenix!”
I hired CHM Injury Attorneys after I got rear-ended and could not be happier with my decision. Darin, Jessica, Libby, Maeve, and the whole team have been awesome! They are knowledgeable and kept me informed throughout the case. Most importantly they helped me get the care I needed when I needed it. With CHM I didn’t feel like just another case. I felt like family. I strongly recommend CHM! They are the best injury lawyers in Phoenix!
Patrick Martin - Google Review
“He was excellent and very professional “
My first engagement with David was for a DUI case, and he was excellent. David was professional, compassionate, and knowledgeable about DUI legislation. He communicated quickly and with great attention to detail. David helped me feel prepared and optimistic about my position. His skills and client-focused approach dramatically reduced my stress and assisted me in achieving a positive conclusion.
William- Avvo Review
“Tim was absolutely amazing and worked diligently”
I had an incident and was given the catch-all charge. There wasn’t really anything I could do by myself to get out of it. Tim was absolutely amazing and worked diligently to ensure that I would have the best possible outcome from my case. Which he successfully achieved! As of right now, I am on the path to having my case fully dismissed. A couple of things that really helped me through this process was that Tim did an amazing job at answering my questions. He was available almost anytime and would respond promptly when he got my emails. He was also very approachable and comforting to be around while we had in person meetings and especially when I was at the court house. I would trust him and the company he works for with any other cases in the future, and as of right now, they will be my first choice if I need a lawyer in the future.
Dylan - AVVO Review
“They went to bat for me in what I would call a difficult Judge in a difficult city in a difficult situation”
First I have to say there are no words to say thank you to the team at CHM Law Firm and special thanks to Dave H, Kyle C., And Kiara C for working for me on my case. I am an RN and have had my nursing license since 1994 with no blemishes. I was involved with an incident that happened on Oct 23 and I was charged with an assault and domestic violence! Wow I was horrified, scared, and in shock… felt like my life was ending. I immediately started calling different law firms but none would get back to me in a timely manor except for CHM law firm. They were smart enough to identify my urgency in my time of troubles. I immediately received a call from Dave H who listened to my story of the events that had landed me in my situation. He actually listened and heard and understood the fear of loosing my nursing career. He provided a very impressive history of his experiences and I immediately know CHM would represent me as if they knew me. I was assigned to Kyle and Kiara who went to work right away. It didn’t matter if it was early in the morning or later in the evening, I knew I had a friend I could call. They went to bat for me in what I would call a difficult Judge in a difficult city in a difficult situation. They presented the facts of the case and was able to get my charges dismissed. I can say THANK YOU, Thank you All day and it wouldn’t be enough to express how grateful and blessed to have such caring and concerned people in my corner. thank you CHM TEAM!!
Fran, Emily Gabel - Google Review
“I was convinced they were the best firm for the job”
After learning my spouse was filing for divorce, I found CHM Law on both Google and Yelp. After my initial consultation, I was convinced they were the best firm for the job. My team of lawyer Judie and paralegal Whitney were incredible, to say the least. They ensured an incredibly smooth process during a very difficult period and obtained a settlement above and beyond my wildest expectations. If I ever get remarried and divorced again, they will be my first call.